The Morbid Equinox — The Hurricane of 1938

Tomorrow, September 21, marks the Fall Equinox. Sixty-nine years ago to the day my grandparents and my father rode out the greatest storm to ever strike New England, while to the west 600 people perished. It was a disaster my grandparents never forgot, something they didn’t talk about much, but with a tinge of fear, making it the ghost story of my childhood, a scary story reinforced by scrapbooks of photographs of storm damage and commemorative editions of the New Bedford Standard Times that detailed the destruction through photographs of wrecked beach cottages, submerged autos, and yachts cast incongruously across highways and train tracks. I pored over those photographs, and asked out loud when something as dramatic might happen again. I was shushed. It’s bad luck to whistle up a storm.
I am reading a good book, A Wind to Shake the World, by Everett S. Allen, the late journalist and Martha’s Vineyard native who spent his career at the Standard-Times, starting as a cub reporter on the day the hurricane struck. The fact this was a hurricane with no name (it occurred before the days when the National Weather Service dubbed them names such as Katrina and Andrew) may account for a lot of the mystery surrounding it. It was the most powerful hurricane to ever hit the eastern seaboard north of North Carolina. It happened unexpectedly, there were no forecasts and it literally caught people unaware, on the beach, closing their summer cottages at the end of the season. People in New York and Boston were unaware of what was happening to their south and east. It was days before the news became known and relief could arrive. It was the storm that punctuated the misery of the Depression, the storm which ended any semblance of colonial bucolic New England that remained, that the Currier & Ives version of New England that existed before the Interstate, an isolated corner of working farms, scrub forests, rich men’s mansions, and remote beaches. It was simply the Storm of ’38.

Driving home to Cape Cod last night from New York City (my flight to Hyannis was cancelled due to fog), was an eerie experience, especially once I passed New Haven and began to flick past the towns which had been devastated by the storm 69 years ago, a landscape tortured and which I read about that morning on the flight to LaGuardia.

Long Island was hit first, around three in the afternoon. New York City saw some strong winds and flooding, but the damage got worse to the east. Fire Island. Point of Woods — the barrier island that runs like a tenuous finger between the Atlantic and the bay behind it was flooded by a tidal wave 35-feet tall, wiping cottages and their occupants off of the sand dunes, blowing them north to the mainland. The Hamptons were hard hit, but Montauk, the commercial fishing haven at the very terminus of Long Island was ruined. Bodies were blown across Block Island Sound to Rhode Island. After the storm, police sent messages downwind to Montauk, seeking identification of victims such as this:

“The little boy found was between 36 and 37 inches tall, weighing forty pounds and was between two and three years old. His hair was medium brown, inclined to be wavy…He wore a dark blue suit with white pearl buttons … the message was addressed to [Montauk] because it was to windward, in terms of the hurricane.”

Across Long Island Sound, in Connecticut, where I drove through the early morning hours, New Haven, the Elm City, lost 42 percent of its trees, losing a beauty it was renowned for. Crossing the bridge in Old Saybrook, over the Connecticut River, I thought of Nils Ek, the captain of the 48-foot cruiser Marpo, who perished while trying to save another man’s yacht.

“After striking the bulkhead two or three times, the craft disappeared, and no trace of her was found after the storm. She is presumed to have slid off into deep water and probably was carried far downstream underwater. Whether Captain Ek fell overboard or had gone below to determine what was wrong with his engine will never be known.”

In New London, the destruction was absolute, sealed by a fire which carried away the commercial center of downtown during the worst of the 120 mph winds. In Mystic, the next town, fish were found in kitchen drawers of flooded houses. A Boston bound train was washed off its tracks outside of Stonington but no passengers were lost and the passengers — mainly prep school students — found refuge in the village. Rhode Island was hit the hardest.

Over 100 perished in Westerly where the high school was turned into a morgue, the shorefront at the Charlestown Breach and Point Judith seemed to take the brunt of the blow. The day after, Allen described the scene:

“Along the shore road back to Misquamicut, the remains of houses are scattered deep on the shore of Brightman’s Pond. Gangs of men comb the coves and fields for bodies; hundreds more are expected to join the search tomorrow, for nearly thirty dead are still missing …”

The story was the same to the east: Narragansett, Wickford, Newport.

As Kurt Vonnegut wrote, “So it goes.”

Downtown Providence was flooded to the second floors of the downtown office buildings. Looters rampaged after the waters receded. People died in Westport, at Horseneck Beach. Padanarum, the yachting center west of New Bedford, was the scene of much maritime mayhem, as the most beautiful yachts ever imagined were dashed against the bridge and causeway at the head of the harbor.

The storm hit on a school day, and in Bristol, Rhode Island, a school bus was flooded. Eight children died. And so it went.

Town after town ravaged by a storm which in the course of three hours — coinciding with high tide — pushed a 35-foot tall water of water before it, drowning those unfortunate enough to be trapped in their collapsing homes, killing fishermen caught unaware at sea, and gruesomely gashing and impaling those caught outdoors with flying debris. A women securing her window bled to death when the glass shattered and cut her jugular vein.

The saddest story related by Allen and the hardest for me to bear as I drove home, occurred beneath the Bourne Bridge, the southernmost span over the Cape Cod Canal. There a house which had washed off its foundation a couple miles to the south, fetched up. When rescuers cut a hole in the roof they discovered four elderly women and an 11-year old boy, drowned in the attic. With them was a local man, about my age . He had been visiting elderly people in his neighborhood, helping them secure their homes and tying up their skiffs. His name was Hayward Wilson.

“At midnight, they found five bodies on the second floor; all had drowned. A bloody bruise was on Wilson’s forehead and his hands were badly bruised and lacerated; he had made a last desperate effort to break through the roof to get the women and little boy out of their water-filled prison.”

He was posthumously awarded the Carnegie Medal for Heroism , the reverse side of which reads: “Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends.”

That bridge was the hardest to cross. With every highway sign, another one of Allen’s anecdotes of tragedy and death, heroism and survival came back to me. I’ll never be able to look at the southern New England shore the same way again.

These pictures say it all. Napatree Point, Rhode Island before the storm.

And after (note the wooden groins, or planks in both pictures for reference.

(photos by the late Leonard R. Greene)

Author: David Churbuck

Cape Codder with an itch to write

0 thoughts on “The Morbid Equinox — The Hurricane of 1938”

  1. You might find lists of the RI victims in the newspapers of the day – Providence Journal comes to mind.

    We left Padanarum that morning, in our 60 foot schooner which never had an engine, and headed south. We were sailing up from Maine in company with another boat, headed for FL for the winter. He, having an engine, anchored in Shelter Island, Long Island, as I recall. Anyway, we were almost drifting in the very light winds, but the heavy swells were telltale of something big coming, so we headed into Block Island, tacked in. My father rowed ashore to the CG station for news. They said hurricane coming, but weren’t allowed to put up hurricane flags yet. Suggested we tie up at steamer wharf. A small schooner tied up ahead of us. By the time CG could fly the hurricane flags, the flag tower had blown down. We were the only vessel to survive on Block Island. CG wouldn’t let us leave for three days because of wreckage out at sea.
    Would like to see Block I pictures taken after the hurricane.

  2. Ironically, I was born on September 21st 1938 at New York’s Lenox HillHospital. My parents tell me the hospital lost power at the moment of my birth. Oddly, for whatever reason, I sometimes wonder if I was brought into the world to replace someone who left it that day.

  3. My mother told me that her dad ,my grandfather Jack Dawson was one of the men searching for bodies in the wake of the storm in Charlestown. She said he pulled up a hand and saw the ring that belonged to a very dear friend.

  4. I was born on that date in 1964 in New York. As a child I remember my dad telling me his grand father and other family members were taken by the storm. My grandfather, my dads dad, would never speak of the storm, not one word. I was wondering if anyone knew where I could get information on the deceased or remembers anyone by the name of Ethier. Oscar, Henry, and Ernest, my grandfather were his sons. Oscar and Henry remained in Rhode Island until their deaths. I hope to move to Rhode Island one day.
    I was born 32 years to the day of the storm,my fondest and most dear memories of a child were our vacations to see my Uncles Henry and Oscar.
    I, too believe there was a reason I was born on that day 32 years after, Rhode Island is in my blood, I have forever since a young child said my home is Rhode Island. I didn’t know until reading this information that my birth fell on the day of my great grandfathers death 32 years earlier. If anyone has any information they are willing to share please contact me. My grandfather, Ernest has now past and my dad, James is 71. I desperately would like to tell him about his grandparents. Thank you

  5. Holly, I can’t exactly tell from your post who is who. If I were you, I would search in ancestry.com. That may at least turn up birth, marriage, death records. Once you have some of that information, you might find marriage or death writeups in the Providence Journal near those days.

  6. Hi Trudy, thanks for the help. It’s been tough finding information. I guess there were or still are alot of Ethier’s in Rhode Island.
    I have learned that alot of my ancestors came from France to Canada then finally settled in Rhode Island and a few in Massachusetts.
    So that was a big help.
    I adore Rhode Island, my fondest childhood memories are of vacationing at my great aunt and uncle’s home. I am hoping to make a trip there very soon. While I’m exploring my family history I hope to find work and an apt. I’ve always known I belonged in Rhode Island! Now I know why! That’s where my closest family started.
    I would love to go to Canada one day and explore there too. But, thank you so much for the information. Ill let you know what I find.

  7. I’ve been looking for a list of Rhode Island deaths caused by the Hurricane of 1938 …
    I found this couple buried in North Burial Ground, Providence, who died on the exact date of the hurricane, in Charlestown (southern tip of Rhode Island), per death record:

    LOXLEY
    Samuel
    Nov. 27, 1868 – Sept. 21, 1938
    his wife
    Hannah A. Grundy
    Nov. 22, 1873 – Sept. 21, 1938

    I’ve entered a photo of their gravestone into Find-A-Grave, and would add the info regarding the hurricane, if that was the cause of their deaths.

  8. Beth, hi, I have been for almost two years trying to find the cemetery, or some type of death record for my great grandfather Nelson Ethier. He was born in Mass. and married to my great grandmother Georgianna Bilodeaux. I was wondering if you remember having come across any info. on that name? If you find out anything can you please let me know? Thank you Holly

  9. I’m looking for information regarding a Katherine (Kate) Maine who drowned at Napatree Point in the hurricane. She was 76 and her beach house was washed into the bay. I remember reading a quote from an article (Westerly Sun, Providence Journal?) about a man trying to save her and having to watch her house float away as she was looking out the attic window and her giving him “a little wave”.

    Kate was the original owner of my house in Willimantic, Ct. and I’m researching it’s history. I have been unable to locate the article. Any help would be appreciated.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.